Charlotte Mason Blog Carnival - March 2013!

Welcome to the March 2013 edition of the Charlotte Mason Blog Carnival!

This month we are talking about: The Sacredness of Personality and since many of the posts are on topic you have a wonderful opportunity to learn about this foundational idea from varying perspectives. And what's truly amazing is just how much wisdom there is in this line-up today! The CM knowledge between the women sharing here is nothing short of remarkable so sit back, relax, and get ready for some great reading!

First, we have The Best Part of Education - Masterly Inactivity and Roller Skates by Nancy Kelly at Sage Parnassus

And from Brandy at Afterthoughts we have Narration and the Single Reading

We also have a long time reader posting with us for the very first time, Marcy, sharing from her new blog From Mother Wit with The Way of the Will: part 1

Next we have some wonderful personal reflections and revelations from Silvia in her post Poetry in Progress over at Silvia Cachia 

And from Megan at The Winding Ascent we have a CM quote:
"Who can take the measure of a child? The Genie of the Arabian tale is nothing to him. He, too, may be let out of his bottle and fill the world. But woe to us if we keep him corked up." (vol.6, p.42)

...and a post: A look at the sacredness of personality through the considerable Mind of a child, A Considerable Speck: Recognizing the Importance of Mind in the Life of a Child and another heartfelt follow-up post, a breath of fresh air, The Sacredness of Personality or Why We're Not the Duggars and It's Still Okay

Lanaya asks a great question in her post, What Are We Prepping Them For? at Delightful Education

Lindafay at Higher Up and Further In helps us problem solve written narration with some excellent points in her not-to-be-missed post, Is Your Child Struggling With Written Narration?

Here's a fun post from Cynthia at Our Journey Westward with an idea on how the kids can paint like Michelangelo: Artist Study: Michelangelo

Roberta delves into how we motivate children to learn in her post, Yet More on Motivation at Letters From Nebby

Tammy at Aut-2B-Home in Carolina gives us a real-life example of how CM's ideas made a difference in her church's afterschool program in Delight in the Lord

Mama Squirrel outlines A natural history lesson: Primrose Seeds for a sixth-grader over at Dewey's Treehouse, causing us to wonder once again about the little life contained in a seedling.

Carol discusses what she has learned about introverted personality in her post, Sacredness of Personality at journey-and-destination

Now here's a post one would hope to share with some select readers over at librivox! Celeste writes about "the fine art of beautiful and perfect speaking" where she shares her discoveries in Arthur Burrell's piece on recitation: Some Thoughts on Volume 1: Recitation at Joyous Lessons.

Also from Joyous Lessons, Angela shares wise words from another buried treasure in the Parent's Review The Archives: Family Bickerings

Nadene shares some of her ultimate goals for her children in what she considers A Sacred Task over at Practical Pages.

Our favorite amiga Amy inspires us to contemplate our role as educators in thoughts on sacredness of personality... at

And last but not least, Jessica tells us how she found herself standing out in the windy cold setting up a pool and why in Personalities and Pools at Under the Willow Oak

If you still find yourself able to read another post, here is my outline which I had prepared prior to receiving all these wonderful posts. And now I'm finding it somewhat unnecessary considering it has all been so well stated already! Well, let's consider it a recap shall we? :) Here you go: 

Could it really be that how we get our children to do their schoolwork will influence their character for the rest of their lives? 

Charlotte Mason seemed to think so.

Here we have a child and a set amount of work that must be done. When the child resists, how do we, as a loving mother, go about helping them?

Do we threaten with the "terrors of the law" - "Do this or else!" Or, do we resort to "Do this for my sake"? What about the subtle cold-shoulder or the exaggerated praise? Do we use these tactics often? Would we use them on a grown adult; an aquaintance or a friend from church?

CM says "Where we teachers err is in stimulating the wrong Desires to accomplish our end."

She claims:
"...for this end a boy learns his lessons, behaves properly, shows good will, produces a whole catalogue of schoolboy virtues and yet his character is being undermined."

"Parents look on with a smile and think that all is well; but Bob or Mary is losing that growing time which should make a self-dependent, self-ordered person, and is day by day becoming a parasite who can go only as he is carried, the easy prey of fanatic or demagogue."
She says "no matter how good the immediate end" of these tactics, a "dread of making them incompetent to conduct their own lives will make us chary of employing means so dangerous."  "Each such desire has its place but the results are disastrous if any one should dominate."

She would prefer we teach them to use their own will to accomplish their work because it is the right thing to do. But how is that done? I've listed a few of CM's methods here: The Habit of Attention

Additionally she claims "It is within a teacher's scope to offer wholesome ambitions to a boy, to make him keen to master knowledge." One such desire "which may well be made to play into the schoolmaster's hands is that of society":
"If they are so taught that knowledge delights them, they will choose companions who share that pleasure. In this way princes are trained; they must know something of botany to talk with botanists, of history to meet with historians; they cannot afford to be in the company of scientists, adventurers, poets, painters, philanthropists or economists, and themselves be able to do no more than 'change the weather and pass the time of day'; they must know modern languages to be at home with men of other countries, and ancient tongues to be familiar with classical allusions. Such considerations rule the education of princes, and every boy has a princely right to be brought up so that he may hold his own in good society, that is, the society of those who 'know.'"
Teach the child the day is likely coming when he will meet with such opportunities as a man. Would he choose to be conversant? Will it matter to him then? 

She goes on to discuss how a teacher's assumptions about the child's dislike of learning is disabling to the child:
"But so besotted is our educational thought that we believe children regard knowledge rather as repulsive medicine than as inviting food. Hence our dependence on marks and prizes, athletics, alluring presentation, any jam we can devise to disguise the powder."
"...he whose mind is sustained by the crutches of emulation and avarice loses that one stimulating power which is sufficient for his intellectual needs. This atrophy of the desire of knowledge is the penalty our scholars pay because we have chosen to make them work for inferior ends."
How sad. If only we would begin, instead, assuming and trusting that:
"...all children, want to know all human knowledge; they have an appetite for what is put before them, and, knowing this, our teaching becomes buoyant with the courage of our convictions." 
So great is the discovery of this natural desire for knowledge in children that teachers described it as:
"'sensing a passage,' is as the striking of a vein of gold in that fabulously rich country, human nature."
Oh, but not my child you say? Well, check the list. Here are a few things CM claims may be hindering that natural desire:

*the talky-talky of the oral lesson and the lecture
*offering matter which no living soul can digest (compilations and text-books)
*stimuli of marks and prizes
*unhealthy play on the desires - coercion by love, fear, anxiety, etc.

There are others like, long lessons, an overemphasis on facts instead of ideas, making all the interesting connections for them in an elaborate lesson prepared by the teacher, etc.which she mentions elsewhere. 

With the right methods and the right books and the right motives, CM would have us believe that the natural desire for knowledge does the rest and the children feed and grow. What do you think?

These additional readings on "the will" may also help with some of the "how-to" of teaching your child to be more self-dependent, self-ordered.

The Habit of Attention
CM Carnival Oct '12 - The Way of the Will 
A Disciplined Will 

We hope you enjoyed this month's carnival! Let us know in the comments if you did!

We'll meet you next month on March 19th at Windy Hill Homeschool to discuss Education is an Atmosphere


  1. Nice job, Naomi :) Can't believe I forgot to post for the carnival again, LOL.

  2. Thank you for hosting--so much great reading!

  3. Thank you for hosting--so much great reading!

  4. Good job, Naomi!

    Tammy's link is going to Nebby's page, FYI.

    I am feasting on these links. All so yummy. :)

  5. Yikes! Never fails, I mix up something or another on these carnivals!! It's all fixed now. Thanks for the heads up Brandy, sorry Tammy!!

  6. Dear Naomi,

    Thank you for taking the time to present such a feast of ideas!

    From joy to joy,


Post a Comment